Which New Hallmark Mystery Movies Will Get Sequels?

Photo: Chris McNally, Holland Roden Credit: ©2024 Hallmark Media/Photographer: Syd Wong

As Countdown To Christmas is fast approaching in mid-October, it means that the newly branded Hallmark Mystery has only a few more premiere announcements in 2024. Most of all, Sleuthers want to know which single-episode mysteries will get sequels.

Here is the latest roundup.

Photo: Paul Campbell, Aimee Garcia Credit: ©2023 Hallmark Media/Photographer: Allister Foster
Photo: Paul Campbell, Aimee Garcia Credit: ©2023 Hallmark Media/Photographer: Allister Foster

Hallmark Mystery Launched In 2024 With Promise Of Multiple Episodes

In early March, HMM rebranded to Hallmark Mystery. Also, Lisa Hamilton Daly spoke to the Hallmark Mysteries & More podcast explaining why they rebranded. In an interview that all Sleuthers should listen to, the EVP of Programming at Hallmark Media explained that they were now going to focus on mysteries. They are ramping up production. 

In addition, she revealed that three was the magic number for mystery viewing success. What seems to happen is that by the time viewers get to the third movie, they are hooked. Moreover, viewership increases exponentially. She also pointed out how there is not an American equivalent to Acorn TV, which specializes in cosy mysteries.

Hallmark is fantastic at branding. Moreover, fans know what to expect when they watch the network. These are not violent or hardcore mysteries that are unsettling. There will be some romance, and definitely some fun characters.

Therefore, now that the network has premiered a cornucopia of single mystery movies, many Sleuthers may want to know which movies will have a sequel.

What Happened To Second Cases Of Mystery Lane Movie?

For months, Sleuthers have been waiting for The Cases Of Mystery Lane sequel starring Aimee Garcia and Paul Campbell. The first was such a success, fans want to know when there will be more.

Hallmark Mysteries & More - Instagram
Hallmark Mysteries & More – Instagram

Paul Campbell recently responded to a comment asking about the second Cases Of Mystery Lane movie. He wrote, “It’s coming. And it’s freakin good.” The word is that it will premiere soon. Perhaps before Christmas programming starts?

Photo: Jodie Sweetin, Stephen Huszar Credit: ©2023 Hallmark Media/Photographer: Courtesy of Brain Power Studio
Photo: Jodie Sweetin, Stephen Huszar Credit: ©2023 Hallmark Media/Photographer: Courtesy of Brain Power Studio

Which Hallmark Mystery Sequels Have Been Filmed?

Have any Hallmark Mystery sequel movies been filmed? There are a couple that can be reported on. Firstly, Stephen Huszar recently shared that he and Jodie Sweetin filmed four more Jane Mysteries.

Photo: Skylar Samuels, Evan Roderick, Kayla Heller Credit: @2023 Hallmark Media/Photographer: Sven Boecker
Photo: Skylar Samuels, Evan Roderick, Kayla Heller Credit: @2023 Hallmark Media/Photographer: Sven Boecker

Second, it looks like they recently filmed a couple of Aurora Teagarden prequel mysteries based on social media and online industry publications. This stars Skylar Samuels as the librarian sleuth, as well as Evan Roderick, and Marilu Henner.

However, Hallmark has not made a formal announcement about this series.

Photo: Marisa McIntyre, Markian Tarasiuk, Katherine McNamara, Sabrina Saudin, Alexander Nunez,Sam Ashe Arnold Credit: ©2023 Hallmark Media/Photographer: Albert Camicioli
Photo: Marisa McIntyre, Markian Tarasiuk, Katherine McNamara, Sabrina Saudin, Alexander Nunez,Sam Ashe Arnold Credit: ©2023 Hallmark Media/Photographer: Albert Camicioli

What About True Justice Sequel?

On Thursday, TV Line answered a fan question inquiring about another True Justice movie, mentioning that the first was in January. They responded with an answer. “I bought your inquiry straight to Hallmark programming EVP Lisa Hamilton Daly, who… had ‘nothing to say’ about further installments. Yet.”

It should be added that Curious Caterer star Nikki DeLoach and her writing partner Megan McNulty write this series.

Photo: Hunter King, Rhiannon Fish Credit: ©2022 Hallmark Media/Photographer: Craig Minielly
Photo: Hunter King, Rhiannon Fish Credit: ©2022 Hallmark Media/Photographer: Craig Minielly

What Other Hallmark Mystery Series Are We Waiting For?

There is a cornucopia of Hallmark Mystery sequels that fans are waiting for news of a sequel. Here are some of the biggest ones mentioned on social media. However, this is by no means all of them.

One of the most recent popular mysteries is Tipline Mysteries, starring Holland Roden and Chris McNally. It premiered on the streamer with a lot of When Calls The Heart fans tuning in. But, this mystery stayed in Peacock’s top five movies for weeks.

Hunter King recently shared that she really wants to make another Nikki & Nora Mystery with Rhiannon Fish.

Many fans are asking for another Haunted Harmony Mystery starring Tamera Mowry-Housley. Will there be more?

Photo: Tamera Mowry-Housley Credit: ©2023 Hallmark Media
Photo: Tamera Mowry-Housley Credit: ©2023 Hallmark Media

While there are many sequel requests, many Sleuthers want a cliffhanger solution to Cut, Color, Murder starring Julie Gonzalo and Ryan McPartlin. Has it been too long for Hallmark to make this movie? Let’s hope not!

It is bad enough that Sleuthers did not get a cliffhanger resolution movie for Mystery 101. It would be great for viewers to get this cliffhanger resolved.

Hallmark Cut Color Murder Photo: Grace Beedie, Ryan McPartlin, Fed Henderson, Julie Gonzalo, Eva Tamargo Credit: ©2021 Crown Media United States LLC/Photographer: Kailey Schwerman
Hallmark Cut Color Murder Photo: Grace Beedie, Ryan McPartlin, Fed Henderson, Julie Gonzalo, Eva Tamargo Credit: ©2021 Crown Media United States LLC/Photographer: Kailey Schwerman

Sleuthers, which Hallmark Mystery sequels do you want to see? There are many that fans loved. Share your comments below.

Georgia Makitalo

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *