Carrie Underwood’s ‘American Idol’ Return Sparks Major Drama

Carrie Underwood is back on American Idol, but this time, she’s sitting behind the judge’s desk instead of performing on stage. The 41-year-old country music superstar, who won the fourth season of American Idol in 2005, is returning to the show as a judge for Season 23. She’ll be joining Luke Bryan and Lionel Richie to form the new judging panel. Carrie is taking over for Katy Perry, who stepped down before the season 21 finale. Fans were excited to see Carrie’s return, but it hasn’t been without some controversy.

Carrie Performing At Trump’s Inauguration

Carrie’s decision to perform at Donald Trump’s inauguration in January 2025 has sparked some backlash. Many fans have criticized her for her choice to support Trump, which has led to mixed reactions from the American Idol audience. However, Carrie is determined not to let this negativity affect her. According to astrology expert Inbaal Hongiman, who spoke with Express US, Carrie’s personality by her Pisces sign—means that she won’t tolerate negativity. “Pisces like Carrie will not accept any bad attitude from anyone,” Hongiman explained. “She will be the one who dreams big on behalf of her acts.”

Carrie’s passion for her contestants is clear. As a Pisces, she is known for her deep empathy and belief that anything is possible. Inbaal suggests that this belief could lead Carrie to clash with her fellow judges, especially if they have a more practical or realistic approach. However, Carrie’s confidence in her contestants’ potential will be an asset to the show.

Carrie and Luke Bryan (who is also a water sign, Cancer) may find common ground because both signs are emotionally driven. Water signs, like Pisces and Cancer, are said to be in tune with their emotions and have a natural understanding of one another. According to Inbaal, Carrie and Luke will likely have a supportive relationship as they share a deep sensitivity. Meanwhile, Lionel Richie, who is a Gemini, will bring a lighter, more adaptable energy to the group. With his fun-loving nature, he might bring some levity to the judging panel.

Host Ryan Seacrest Stirs Things Up

On the other hand, the host who might stir things up is Ryan Seacrest, a Capricorn. As a Capricorn, Ryan is known for his business-minded approach and practicality, which could clash with Carrie’s more emotional perspective. Capricorn signs are often focused on results and may not value artistic creativity as much as other signs, which could lead to some disagreements between Ryan and the more intuitive judges.

Despite any potential clashes, astrology expert Inbaal believes that the judging panel will have a lot of fun. “Carrie and Lionel are both Mutable signs, which makes them adaptable and open to change,” Inbaal said. This shared adaptability could lead to a strong bond between Carrie and Lionel. They may even become the “giggly pair” of the panel, enjoying each other’s company while helping contestants through their journey.

Carrie Underwood’s return to American Idol is shaping up to be an exciting one. While her role as a judge will have some challenges, especially with the diverse personalities on the panel. Her passion for her contestants and her positive outlook will undoubtedly make her a fan favorite. As the new season kicks off, fans can look forward to seeing how she balances her caring nature with her role as a tough but fair judge. Will Carrie continue to receive backlash? Is Ryan Seacrest going to cause trouble with Carrie? Let us know your thoughts in the comments.