Hallmark Announces Two More ‘True Justice’ Mysteries Starring Nikki DeLoach, Benjamin Ayres

Hallmark Mystery’s True Justice is returning with two more movies. This is the Nikki DeLoach and Megan McNulty series about a group of college law students who solve cases for those who cannot defend themselves.
Here are all the details on the two upcoming movies.

Hallmark Mystery Filming Two True Justice Movies
On Wednesday, Deadline reported that Hallmark has two movies in production. They are the second and third True Justice movies. This series stars Nikki DeLoach, Benjamin Ayres, Katherine McNamara, and Markian Tarasiuk. They are currently in Ontario filming two movies, with the working titles of Eye For An Eye, and Lost Love.
In Eye For An Eye the Scooby Doo team of Justice Warriors have their work cut out for them. A mother has been wrongly accused of murder. Now, the team needs to reopen the case and find evidence to exonerate her. In this mystery, they have to go undercover. They need to pose as wealthy parents at a school. Can they find the evidence in time?
As for Lost Love, ” Our Warriors work to not only exonerate Marianne for the murder of her missing fiancé but to bring to light a web of counterfeit jewels along the way.”

Nikki DeLoach Is Back With Megan McNulty
Nikki DeLoach is back as Professor Ambrose, as well as writer and producer of these two movies. Her writing and producing partner Megan McNulty are thrilled there is more. Nikki shared a statement about this passion project that she loves so much.
Megan McNulty and I are thrilled to continue the True Justice franchise on Hallmark Mystery. In the first installment, our characters, these law school students, come together to help one of their own, but in the process they find a higher calling. In the second and third installments, they follow this calling, by banding together, utilizing their individual skills, to liberate others in need.
She also promised that there would be romance, and “more justice to be served.”
In this series, McNamara plays Casey Barlowe, Tarasiuk as Eli Flint, and Ayres, as D.A. Quinn.

Benjamin Ayres Is Back For This Hallmark Mystery
In this Hallmark Mystery, Benjamin Ayres portrays the D.A. who forces the students to find the evidence. On Instagram, Ben wrote, “We’re back! So incredibly fortunate to continue telling more True Justice stories thanks to the minds and creativity of @nikdeloach and @megmcnut.”
View this post on Instagram
Sleuthers, are you happy to see True Justice return?
- Hearties Demanding Hallmark Do This One Thing About Their Favorite Series - March 25, 2025
- Hearties Have ‘When Calls The Heart’ Season 13 Wishlist - March 24, 2025
- ‘When Calls The Heart’ Fans Wonder What Happened To This Young Character - March 24, 2025