‘Bachelor In Paradise’ Susie Breaks Silence On Jeremy Drama
Susie Evans was only briefly on Season 10 of Bachelor In Paradise, but her name has been brought up on the show for weeks. It all started when Jeremy Simon gave his rose to Bailey Brown, a decision that ultimately made Susie quit the show.
Jeremy expressed regret over not getting a chance to explore things with Susie. But he neglected to tell Bailey how he was feeling. Instead, Brian Autz took matters into his own hands and broke the news to Bailey about Jeremy’s lingering feelings for Susie.
Jeremy and Bailey have since given their sides of the drama. But Susie Evans has kept her silence until now. Keep reading to find out what really happened with her and Jeremy.
Susie Evans Spills What Bachelor In Paradise Viewers Didn’t See On Her Date With Jeremy
Jeremy only went on one date with Susie, but that was enough to make him smitten. He’s certainly not the first man in Bachelor Nation who couldn’t get Susie out of his mind. Season 26 Bachelor Clayton Echard sent Susie home but then regretted it. He gave Rachel Recchia and Gabby Windey the boot and begged Susie for a second chance. Susie and Clayton dated for months before calling it quits. He recently gave romance with Rachel Recchia a second chance. It didn’t end well.
In a shocking twist, it didn’t end well for Brian when he got involved in the Susie/Jeremy/Bailey drama. The rest of the cast called him out for breaking bro code. Jeremy was able to sweet-talk Bailey out of quitting the show.
But according to Susie, there wasn’t any drama to begin with. She returned to The Viall Files podcast to share her side of the situation. She was a guest last month after her shocking decision to quit Bachelor In Paradise. During that interview, she expressed disappointment in her time on Season 10.
In her most recent interview, Susie opened up about what viewers didn’t see on her date with Jeremy. She said that she knew during the date that Jeremy wasn’t going to choose her during the rose ceremony and that she had “no chance” with him.
“It was very clear that he was like, ‘I have been growing something with Bailey. We’ve been here for longer. I’m actually shocked about finding someone so quickly.’ I remember being like, ‘Oh, okay, so I’m going home,'” Susie recalled.
Where She Stands With Bailey Brown Now
Some viewers still think Susie Evans will make a dramatic return to Bachelor In Paradise. But if she does, the show has kept it top secret.
It seems unlikely that Susie would return to stir up more drama. Especially after revealing on the podcast that she’s “cool” with Bailey now. Susie reached out after the show and let Bailey know what Jeremy said during their date.
Let us know in the comments what you think about Susie reaching out to Bailey.
- Prayers Pour In For ‘General Hospital’ Star After Suffering Devastating Death - November 11, 2025
- ‘Wheel Of Fortune’ Ryan Seacrest Has Fans Worried For His Health - November 11, 2025
- ‘DWTS’ Frontrunner Injured During Rehearsals - November 11, 2025