‘American Idol’ Fans Think ‘Teenage Girls’ Have Chosen Winner

American Idol fans think that teenage girls have chosen the winner. This comes after the Top 5 were revealed on last night’s Mother’s Day episode. The competition has been hard. However, it has been amazing to watch. There are a lot of talented artists still on the show. However, some people may not be happy about who they think is going to win. Keep reading to find out more about this situation.
American Idol Narrows Down The Top 5
American Idol has narrowed down their Top 5. They did this on last night’s episode, which was the Mother’s Day episode. The contestants had to sing one Disney song and then one song dedicated to Mother’s Day. They all had great performances. Slater forgot the beginning of the words, but it did not stop him one bit. Luke even applauded him for moving on so gracefully. The Top 5 includes Slater Nalley, Breanna Nix, John Foster, Jamal Roberts, and Thunderstorm Artis. This left Mattie Pruitt and Gabby Samone eliminated. However, it is great that they both made it this far. Disney night part 2 will be on tonight. Fans cannot wait to see who makes it through and are voting for their favorites.

Fans Think Teenage Girls Have Chosen The Winner
American Idol fans think that teenage girls are the only reason John Foster is still in the competition.
-
Judges reaction to John advancing. Anyone catch the absolute shock from the judges there? They are a lot of us in that moment, too, lol. I do think he wins, though. He’s got the teenage girl vote
-
I think they were shocked to see which 3 remained, and knowing they were going to lose Gabby, Thunderstorm or both.
- I’m 14 and every night i am voting not necessarily for john but i am voring
- Just posted the same dang thing. Usually they try to appear more neutral, but we KNOW they were like WTF tonight… and rightfully so
-
As I said on another post, this is only the second episode I’ve watched this season. That said, my quick take on John is that he’s that one guy who has a good but not great voice who always lasts way longer than he should based talent, but rarely wins the whole show.
Yikes. John did have some supporters backing him up, though.
It seems as though fans think that teenage girls are the only reason John Foster has gone through. They think this will be the only reason he wins. However, there are people who like John Foster and backed him up, saying the screeching usually comes from his family and friends. Also, some fans are unsure about teenagers even watching the show and voting. What do you think about this? Do you think teenage girls are pushing John Foster through? Sound off in the comments below. We would love to hear your thoughts on this situation.
- Kristen Doute and Luke Broderick Welcome First Child Into The World - June 13, 2025
- ‘American Idol’ John Foster And Breanna Nix Shock With New Duet - June 13, 2025
- ‘DWTS’ Former Contestant Has Warrant Out For Arrest In Florida - June 13, 2025
Well, I’d like to be a teenage girl again but I’m a really cool gram and I love John, Slater and Thunderstorm.
I’m a 77 year old woman not a teenager! I love John’s voice and songs. May be because I love country music. You can understand the words!
I’m 54 years old. I love John and Slater”s voice! It reminds me of old school country and that’s what we need back! I hope one of them win!
I like John and I’m not a teenager. He reminds me of a young Alan Jackson. The talent has been phenomenal this season! All are great!
I am hoping Breanna Nix wins. She has a beautiful voice. But she is not your “typical” idol. One of the men will most likely win.