Hallmark Bringing Back Lori Loughlin’s ‘Garage Sale Mysteries’: Details

Photo: Lori Loughlin; Sarah Strange Credit: Copyright 2018 Crown Media United States LLC/Photographer: Ryan Plummer

Sleuthers, have you heard that you can now watch Lori Loughlin’s classic Hallmark Signature Mystery Series, Garage Sale Mysteries?

We have all the information you need to see amateur sleuth Jennifer Shannon and her best pal, and business partner Dani solves those fabulous mysteries!

How Can You Watch Lori Loughlin’s Garage Sale Mysteries On Hallmark?

On Friday, Hallmark Now shared on Twitter, “#GarageSaleMysteries are now streaming on #HallmarkMoviesNow. Watch the first three movies in the series this weekend!”

Hallmark Now is Hallmark’s streaming channel. Subscribers can watch a cornucopia of feel-good movies and mysteries on this streaming service.

In addition, they shared a video preview from Garage Sale Mysteries. There is also information that every Thursday in July, they are adding another movie in Lori Loughlin’s series.

Currently, these titles are available on Hallmark Now: Garage Sale Mystery, All That Glitters, and The Deadly Room. That means on Thursday, July 28, The Wedding Dress will be added to the streaming network.

However, there are still an additional 11 movies in the series. They have not shared any information on whether they will add those to their service anytime soon.

Lori Loughlin starred in the Hallmark Signature Mystery, based on the Suzi Weinert mysteries, between 2013-2019, portraying the clever garage sale enthusiast, Jennifer Shannon. Jennifer’s keen eye could spot an extraordinary find at even the most disorganized sale, while her inquisitive mind solved mysteries.

The mysteries were like a treasure hunt. You never knew what direction they would lead, but they were always entertaining. Yet, on March 15, 2019, Hallmark Channel broke Sleuthers’ hearts and stopped making the mysteries. That was because of Lori’s legal issues.

Hallmark wrote on Twitter, “We are saddened by the recent news surrounding the college admissions allegations. We are no longer working with Lori Loughlin and have stopped development of all productions featuring Lori on the Crown Media Family Network channels — including #GarageSaleMysteries.”

They were in the middle of filming the second of three movies when they stopped production, and Loughlin was let go.

Photo: Lori Loughlin Credit: Photo Credit: Copyright 2014 Crown Media United States, LLC/Photographer: Bettina Strauss
Photo: Lori Loughlin
Credit: Photo Credit: Copyright 2014 Crown Media United States, LLC/Photographer: Bettina Strauss

Watch Lori Loughlin In When Calls The Heart

Besides watching Lori Loughlin in Garage Sale Mysteries, you can also watch her on When Calls The Heart on Hallmark Now. The Fuller House star portrays Abigail Stanton in Seasons 1-5 and a few episodes of Season 6.

After Operation Varsity Blues revealed that the Hallmark mainstay was involved, they halted WCTH. Brian Bird later explained that they had to either cut her out of the remaining Season 6 episodes or the show would be done.

Therefore, between Garage Sale Mysteries and When Calls The Heart, Lori disappeared from Hallmark altogether. While WCTH was available on Hallmark Now, This mystery news is exciting. That is because Garage Sale Mysteries was one of the network’s best-ever mystery series.

However, Lori has done her time and has moved on. Just recently Loughlin was amongst other Hallmark stars when her friend Holly Robinson Peete hosted a charity event, and when HRP got a star on the Hollywood Walk of Fame.

The When Calls The Heart stars have made it clear that they want Lori back in Hope Valley. Could this GSM news mean that Hearties are one step closer to the return of Abigail Stanton? That is hard to know. But, all antennas are up to see if there are clues and evidence that point to this conclusion.

Other Hallmark Mysteries On Hallmark Now

Sleuthers should note that Hallmark Now also has other mysteries including Murder She Baked, Chronicle Mysteries, Matchmaker Mysteries, Martha’s Vineyard Mysteries, Hailey Dean, Aurora Teagarden, and Crossword Mysteries.

Georgia Makitalo


  1. Great Mysteries
    Lori is really good
    Please bring her back to
    What warms the Heart & other series she was in

  2. Will Garage sale movies be on the regular Hallmark mystery and movie channel? I have Spectrum and would like to know what channel it will be on?

  3. I watch garage sale mysteries with my wife and as far as mysteries go… they are outstanding. I honestly believe that Lori Laughlin did her time- even though the whole college thing was like “making an example” of someone for all the wrong reasons. It would be a good business decision for Hallmark to bring her back for new shows or restart the “garage sale” series- if it’s not broke- don’t fix it… it seemed to me that the show and its characters had good chemistry. (It seemed to work well enough for “SIGNED, SEALED, AND DELIVERED…” (just a thought…)

  4. I miss Lori on garage sale mysteries. You need to let her act again. Her past is behind her like many people in this world can go on doing what they love. The public would be so happy to see her again on this show. It was a fabulous hit !!!

    1. A ex-con should not be on a family center channel. We should not reward criminals. This is why are children morals is are in a mess today. Please Hallmark Channel stop show so good moral and cut Lori Loughlin movie from your line-up.

      1. A family-entered channel should forgive, shouldn’t it? Isn’t that what Jesus told us to do? And for Slea who says to “replace Lori with someone with morals”, well, whoever has not sinned – cast the first stone. That’s in the Bible as well. So forgive, forget and move on. She’s a fantastic actress who made a mistake, did her time, paid the fee and did her community service. So bring her back!

      2. ex means paid in full. There’s lots worse examples in the entertainment industry. Besides, role models are best when they’re in the home. Everything else is a crap shoot.

  5. I am glad that Garage Store Mysteries is back& hope they make new ones I wish Hallmark had stuck with Lori Loughlin instead of benig unsupportive after they earned them so much money.

  6. Thank Heavens they are back. Long overdue. Best in the murder mystery series. Hallmark should broadcast any new that were filmed but held back.

  7. Please continue with garage sale mysteries. One of my favorite shows with Steve Bacic and Lori Loughlin and the entire crew. It was like they were meant to be together. Love the whole family and the nightly meals around the table. Romance ,journey and a triumph!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *